Webinar Information

This further explains some of the content of my webinar tomorrow:


If you are going to be successful in the fall with your online language instruction, you’re going to have to get your kids focused on the message and not on the language when you use the ZOOM platform.

Despite your frustrations this spring using Zoom to teach a language, and no one has been immune to that chaos, I am of the opinion that if you just align your instruction with the research and the Communication standard, you will succeed in the fall using the ZOOM platform .

ZOOM lends itself to online language teaching!

So today I am going to use the Card Talk activity (a.k.a. Circling with Balls) to show you how to reach kids online and how to grab and keep their attention.

Card Talk and One Word Images are both almost 20 years old, and so are fairly rudimentary, but I don’t have time to demo both, so we’ll just use the ultra-simple Circling with Balls. If you have The Big CI Book and want to check out One Word Images, you can find that oldie-but -goodie as Strategy #3 of 27 strategies on page 76.

I’ll give you one lego of the set. But it’s an important lego, because it contains the DNA for everything else you will use for online success using Zoom.

Use Your Hands and Feet. Stay in Your Body When You Teach

What I want you to focus on above all as I demo this activity, is how I use my hands and feet. I center my instruction in my hands and feet and not in my brain (which is the land of “What Do I Do Next?” and the fear that comes with it.

Centering your instruction in your hands and feet and keeping good eye contact with your students are very factors in making Circling with Balls/Card Talk work.

Then we can process after the demo in a Q and A format, which should last about 15 minutes. Questions?

Further information:

I was going to name the title of this webinar today “Teaching to the Standard and in Alignment with the Research Using the ZOOM platform.”

However, I didn’t, because few language teachers actually do that. We need to all become big girls and girls and admit it. Most of us mix our CI instruction with either the traditional textbook or with traditional TPRS/CI instruction. But the standard and the research don’t mix at all with those two things.

The result of this unfortunate mixing is that most “CI teachers” don’t teach to the Communication standard and to its major support document, the Three Modes of Communication, and so they don’t teach in alignment with the research. Let’s change that.

Before COVID, language teachers got away with not teaching to the standards and in alignment with the research because they were in a classroom, as per:

1. They could give tests in a classroom. That makes most of the students show up, but in the form of a captive audience who automatically resist such physical confinement.

3. Teachers could speak English while they taught in their physical classroom. It seemed acceptable. But a deep dive into the research that the use of English is completely unacceptable in a WL classroom.

4. When the term CI became all the vogue, they could just tell people they were doing CI. Who knew? The result was that, over time, the promising and exciting things that Blaine Ray and Susan Gross were doing 20 years ago got watered down into an ineffective blob that didn’t work. That is where we are now.

5. They could favor the few students in the classroom who were good readers and good memorizers, those few who were fast processors. The terrible result was that the rest languished, were called lazy, inattentive, etc. But if a child doesn’t understand, it is never their fault.

So the watered-down and distorted form of CI instruction that I am describing here works in a classroom, but it doesn’t work in online instruction.

COVID “outed” this ineffective and watered-down version of Krashen’s research. When COVID hit, and teachers were forced to hit the ZOOM airwaves, with all its challenges, kids just tuned out en masse. Why?

It’s not the fault of the platform – it’s the fact that language teachers this spring have not been teaching in accordance with the Communication standard and with its major supporting document, the Three Modes of Communication. They weren’t teaching in alignment with the research.

This and later online trainings will provide language teachers with a step-by-step process of how to make online language instruction work for them and their students.

Luckily, it’s almost June and the current Zoom disaster – no one’s fault – will end and we can be ready to teach online in the fall by working hard now over the summer months together to ensure that we are ready.

All we have to do is align our online instruction with the Communication standard and the research, and Zoom provides that capacity even better than the physical classroom, given my four points above.

Success is ours if we merely understand and apply the true bedrock concept of comprehensible input – that the only way to be successful when teaching languages online – or in a physical classroom – is to get your students focused on the message.

The research makes it quite clear that when the thinking mind, the conscious mind, is involved, the language can’t be acquired. Now think about whether you were doing that or not before COVID hit.

In recent months, have your students been focused on the message being presented in the TL on the ZOOM platform, or were they doing worksheets and using their conscious minds as they think their way through class?

Thinking is boring in language classes. But focusing on the message can be lots of fun! So that’s the main thing you have to look into as you begin to arm yourself with all sorts of good strategies for the fall, and be ready for either or both instructional formats.

Right now, are you focused on the message or on the form of the English language used to deliver it? I will keep asking this question.

Do you still find it important to explain the verbs, the subject-verb agreement, being used in these sentences? Do you still find it important to give a test to see if certain of the words from some list have been “acquired”?

Is assessment more important to you than speaking to your students in the language? Do you still think that you can provide an equitable language experience for all your students using those boring little novels, which divide classes down socio-economic and racial lines in cruel ways?

If you are going to be successful in the fall with your online instruction, you’re going to have to learn how to get your kids focused on the message, and forget the rest.

When your students, bathing in the only medium that is needed for acquisition, the unconscious mind, are focused on the message being delivered by you in the target language, they acquire the language. When they are forced to do worksheets and other activities that engage their conscious faculty, you waste valuable time that could be used for engaging their interest in your messages in the TL.

I hope you can see now that the problem of online language instruction is entirely a problem of whether you are (a) engaging the conscious minds of the students in your online or physical classroom, or (b) whether you are engaging their unconscious mind.

So it’s not that big a problem, is it? If we understand the problem we can create a solution for it!

Your students’ focusing on the message gets the job done for you, but doing worksheets or other “CI activities” that DO NOT ENGAGE THE UNCONSCIOUS MIND OF THE LEARNER SO THAT THEY ARE NOT FOCUSED ON THE MESSAGE,, either in an online or live setting, does NOT get the job done.

So, if you are expecting your online students to do worksheets, take tests, speak in the target language, or write in it (ANY FORM OF OUTPUT IN THE FIRST YEAR), then 50 years of research is there to inform you that you should stop doing that. Instruction that requires output in the form of speech or writing has a completely deleterious effect on children in beginning classes.

Don’t break your students with forced output. We break animals, not humans. Take a deep dive into the what the Communication standard and the research are REALLY about, and then you will understand that if you are going to reach your students using an online platform like Zoom, you are going to have to drop the worksheets, the written and spoken output, and all those fake CI activities that you can purchase by the millions online but never seem to work as promised.

Of course, you need to grade them! But why not assess your online students in a way that stays in alignment with the standard and the research? IT’S MUCH EASIER TO GRADE STUDENTS WHEN YOU ALIGN WITH THE STANDARD AND THE RESEARCH.

[Note: I mentioned the words “standard” and “research” around 50 times in the above text. I must be on to something. I must be pointing you in a safe direction in your online instruction.]



5 thoughts on “Webinar Information”

  1. I wonder how we will have students interact with us while we are co-narrating OWIs, or Card Talk, for that matter. With Zoom, will we ask them all to have their microphones on so that they can respond with some spontaneity? Will we mute students ourselves who are responding but we see as disruptive? That is a very fine line. It really makes us more authoritative, and potentially suppressive, than being in a classroom where we have to roll with comments made unexpectedly by students.

    I’ll try to attend this Zoom session, Ben. In case I can’t, I hope you’ll have another.

    1. Maybe through a google form you could take surveys asking students to submit possible story details. Then you can choose the details at random and place them into a story. Kind of like those story dice I’ve seen. I have seriously dragged my feet with this distance learning thing but see that I’m gonna have to get with the program.

    2. Sean do you have the book? Here is the information about the Zoom classes. I’ll quickly put it here bc I have to jet –

      INV ZOOM SCHEDULE – May 18, 2020

      1. The group is limited to 22 people. If someone drops out, someone on the waiting list gets in.
      2. Four meetings per week, according to this schedule:

      Monday – 2:00 p.m. Eastern Time
      Tuesday – 3:00 p.m. Eastern Time
      Wednesday – 4:00 p.m. Eastern Time
      Thursday – 5:00 p.m. Eastern Time

      You can attend just one or all five of the sessions, but you’ll get a Zoom invite every day.
      3. 30-minute sessions. Limited teacher talk; no Q and A.
      4. When we are ready, we will take entire journeys around the Star Sequence, and not just work in the Create phase.
      5. Only when everyone is ready (i.e. has command of all five phases of the star), will we move to Category B.
      6. Since this is a pilot, we don’t know how long it will take to get through the book. It doesn’t matter. What matters is that we go slowly and repeat lessons, hence the five days a week option. This is body-based teaching and it’s not easy. Certain teachers will be quite content to just learn the heavy Category A artillery offered in a trip through the Star Sequence. That may be all they want to deal with right now and I can certainly understand that. That (Cat. A) shouldn’t take long to master. Others will want to go full monty on all six categories. That will take longer. Obviously, teachers attending all five sessions in any given week will get the training at a deeper level, but the idea of making y’all spend 90 minutes on a Zoom call when you are already so overwhelmed is not going to work; it’s just unnecessary, as long as you do the reading.
      7. This book is written with NEW teachers in mind.
      8. Once you have command over the Invisibles approach, do not use it with students who didn’t have it in level 1. It will backfire on you.
      9. If you are not wanting to go deep and master this method, please tell me so that I can offer your spot to someone on the waiting list.
      10. If I can’t make it to a session on a certain day, Greg Schwab, who has three years of experience with the Invisibles, will sit in for me. As others in the group become more adept at it, they may sit in to lead the discussion at times as well. There will be no break or cancellations of any of our sessions.

      Let’s recapitulate – 22 teachers limit; 30-minute classes; 15 min. Q and A. 4 sessions per week. Attend the sessions you can.
      If anything comes up, my email is benslavic@yahoo.com. Buckle up. Seat back straight and tray table in the upright and locked position. Get ready to fly!

      If you are new, here is the reading from the book that we are currently working on:


      Don’t forget flower power!

      Zoom Assignment #1:

      1. In the book, read the introductory pages of the Invisibles book (pp. 6-10).
      2. Next, read first about Henry (pp. 11-18) up to Optional Question Set 1 (p. 18).
      3. Then about Pamela (pp. 36-39).
      4. Next, make up your own card to share in class as per the instructions given in Category A. We will make an Invisibles classroom out of the Zoom format. It’ll be just like starting the year with real students, only with each other. Our language will be French.
      5. Read about Walk Before You Talk pp. 237-240. Looks easy. Isn’t.

      What are we doing in this, our first Invisibles French class? We will imitate what we will do in our first class back with our students in the fall, if we choose to incorporate this way of teaching into our repertoire. Our goal in this first lesson is therefore to immediately draw the kids into the community with Card Talk. Get it? We will “draw” the students into class. It’s better than a big lecture on the rules in order to kill time till the next batch of victims walks in on that first day….

      Keywords for Assignment #1: feet, WBYT, flower power

      Zoom Assignment #2:

      ADVICE: During the week after each session, get this method into your body by practicing what you learned in the previous session on your family or any canines in the vicinity (don’t try this on a cat). Then, if you wish, practice with your Zoom team in the second half of class. The groups are small for this reason. Just our small team, keeping in mind that no one teaches in the same way and that there is no one right way to do this work. The Invisibles approach is just a pathway and we can go as fast or as slow, skipping or running, laughing or crying, etc. when we are on it. It’s up to us. The book was crafted with this in mind, that we all teach differently.

      So, for Assignment #2:

      1. Go bqck and repeat everything you did for Zoom Homework #1. Repetition brings perfection.
      2. Then, add in the first of the Optional Questioning Levels – the “time of day” option (p. 18).
      3. Next, add in the first job in Hub A – the artist (pp. 245-247).

      Keywords for Assignment #2:

      Zoom Assignment #3:

      1. In assignment #1 you learned and practiced implementing the main questioning levels (1-4). In assignment #2 you added in the first question in Optional Questioning Level 1 (p. 18) – morning, afternoon, evening. Now, in assignment #3, you will add in the second question in Optional Questioning Level 1 – at what specific time of day is this tableau vivant happening? (p. 18)
      2. So at this point, to make it perfectly clear, when going through the questioning levels for Category A, you have asked a total of six questions of your students:

      (a) How they are doing (Town Meeting).
      (b) Who the character is and what they do (ex. Henry plays the violin).
      (c) Where the character is (Canada).
      (d) Whom the character is with (a giant).
      (e) If this happened in the morning, afternoon or evening (morning).
      (f) What time specifically in the morning this happened (5:00 a.m.).

      Now you have flower power!

      Keywords for Assignment #3:

      3. Next, start getting your student jobs in place by hiring your first two students and putting them at the table to your right in Hub A. These are the artists (pp. 245-247).

      Zoom Assignment #4:

      Keywords for Assignment #1: feet, WBYT, flower power

  2. My only comment on teaching languages online is that it can be done and that it can be easier than teaching regular physical classes (not a lot but easier), and require far less planning.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Search

Get The Latest Updates

Subscribe to Our Mailing List

No spam, notifications only about new products, updates.

Related Posts

CI and the Research (cont.)

Admins don’t actually read the research. They don’t have time. If or when they do read it, they do not really grasp it. How could

Research Question

I got a question: “Hi Ben, I am preparing some documents that support CI teaching to show my administrators. I looked through the blog and

We Have the Research

A teacher contacted me awhile back. She had been attacked about using CI from a team leader. I told her to get some research from

The Research

We don’t need any more research. In academia that would be a frivolous comment, but as a classroom teacher in languages I support it. Yes,



Subscribe to be a patron and get additional posts by Ben, along with live-streams, and monthly patron meetings!

Also each month, you will get a special coupon code to save 20% on any product once a month.

  • 20% coupon to anything in the store once a month
  • Access to monthly meetings with Ben
  • Access to exclusive Patreon posts by Ben
  • Access to livestreams by Ben